PIERRE – During his tenure as chief justice of the South Dakota Supreme Court, David Gilbertson, not only dispensed justice, he also saved lives. That was part of the message he delivered Wednesday in his last State of the Judiciary message to the Legislature.
“I leave with satisfaction knowing that there are people alive today who would not otherwise be without our drug, DUI, veterans and mental health courts,” Gilbertson told a joint session of the Legislature. “Our goal was to swell the employment rolls, not the cemeteries.”
After a 34-year judicial career and spending the last 19 as chief justice, Gilbertson faces mandatory retirement. During his message he looked back at the programs that helped save lives.
In addition to saving lives, the special courts are saving money. Gilbertson said a year in the DUI and drug courts costs $8,015 while a year in the penitentiary costs about $22,000.
Drug, DUI and veterans courts served 594 participants in 2018. Of their 135 graduates, only 18 percent have reoffended.
“That’s a substantially higher success rate than the 43 percent success rate for people paroled from the penitentiary,” Gilbertson said.
In 2017 the Legislature found ways to help people in the court system who have mental health issues. Legislation passed that year changed the wait time for competency hearings from as much as six months to an average of just 37 days. The legislation expanded the number of competency evaluators from six to 31.
“It goes a long way to ensure statewide coverage,” Gilbertson said of the changes. “No longer do all roads lead to Yankton and the Human Services Center located there.”
There are three veterans treatment courts in Minnehaha, Pennington and Codington counties. All programs are under the direction of a judge who is a veteran and can understand the challenges they face.
The veterans court is assisted by the Veterans Administration and, when appropriate, allows access to VA inpatient treatment.
“The veterans treatment courts stand alone among all our problem-solving court programs to offer inpatient services,” Gilbertson said.
The Rural Attorney Program has grown to include contracts with 25 rural counties to help provide lawyers in underserved areas. Last year the program was expanded to include municipalities with populations of 3,500 or less. The first to sign on were Elk Point and Sisseton.
“Not one attorney who has gone into the program later left rural practice due to lack of available legal work,” Gilbertson said. “The need is there, and the need is being met.”
Gilbertson refused to make any pronouncements about what the future will hold for the justice system in South Dakota. He noted that future decisions will be guided by the Constitution, the statutes and “the goal of maintaining a peaceful resolution of the citizens’ disputes.”
“The people within the judicial system come and go, but the fundamental basics remain the same,” Gilbertson said. “We do not want to become a legal dinosaur lumbering off into oblivion.”
